The Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE) and the Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) have collaborated to form a Tax Reforms Commission, comprising several eminent thinkers. Currently, tax is a crucial issue in the media, and our lenders prioritize revenue collection over growth and employment. The commission highlights several flaws in the existing tax system. It is neither citizen-friendly, transparent, stable, nor predictable. Faced with increasing budgetary difficulties, reliance on ad-hoc measures has grown, leading to arbitrary withholding income taxes, turnover taxes, taxes on deemed incomes, and arbitrary revisions of tax rates. Approximately 68% of revenue is collected through excessive use of withholding and minimum tax regimes. The fragmented system, with numerous exemptions and rates, creates complexity and confusion for taxpayers. Problems include a broken refund system, high compliance costs, and a predatory Tax Authority. The budget period is marked by extreme uncertainty and speculation due to this approach to taxation. This arbitrary approach has resulted in numerous court cases and reversals of initiatives. More taxes are not the solution to deep structural fiscal policy issues where expenditure control is not possible.
According to the press release issued by PIDE, these statements were made during a press conference at the National Press Club in Islamabad, where Dr. Nadeem ul Haque, Vice Chancellor of PIDE, Dr. Ali Salman, Founder of PRIME, and Dr. Mahmood Khalid, Senior Research Economist at PIDE, addressed the audience.
They further stated that our approach emphasizes developing a predictable tax policy to build trust between citizens and the government. Key recommendations include simplification and harmonization of the tax system to facilitate taxpayers and ease tax payments, which is more effective than arbitrary measures imposed annually.
Eliminating categories such as filer/non-filer and registered/unregistered for sales tax alone would compensate for many arbitrary tax measures. Reducing reliance on revenue collection through tariffs, additional customs duties, and other arbitrary measures has eroded confidence and closed the economy, leading to declining investment and growth. Long-term goals should include openness with low tariffs, not arbitrarily disturbed by any government. Automation and digitization to eliminate direct interaction between taxpayers and the tax authority are crucial. Transparency and digitization are key for tax administration, along with necessary changes in human capital and FBR service organization.
The Commission has worked tirelessly to ensure that reforms will not result in revenue loss and will lead to revenue growth. The proposed policy relies on simplification, harmonization, and improved FBR administration through digitization. Conservative estimates suggest direct revenue gains of at least Rs 4 trillion in the first three years, with significant benefits to the economy in terms of higher investment, growth, and job creation.
Key problems and recommendations highlighted by the Commission include: reliance on tariffs is outdated.
Pakistan has become increasingly isolated due to a closed economy. Strong policy commitment to openness is necessary to benefit from global trade. Decreasing tariffs has shown positive impacts on revenues and substantial reductions in smuggling and mis-invoicing. Zero-rated import of plant and machinery, industrial raw materials, and intermediate goods should be implemented. Withdrawal of regulatory duty (RD), additional custom duties (ACD), and withholding income tax on imports is also recommended. The decades-old GST/VAT agenda needs to be firmly implemented. Problems with sales tax registration, harmonization, digitization, and the refund system should be resolved this year. Key reforms include harmonization of GST/VAT and no new exemptions on GST except in areas such as education and health. A fully functional GST/VAT system must be a performance goal for FBR with consequences. With a good GST in place, we should consider lowering the rate. Existing literature indicates that countries like India, Georgia, and Mexico, which shifted from high GST (17 to 19%) to VAT with a low rate (7 to 10%), have experienced an immediate positive impact on the tax-to-GDP ratio by 3 to 4%. PIDE research shows that in the short run, on average, a 1% increase in GST increases revenues by 2%, while in the long run, FBR revenues tend to decrease by 4% rates. Over the long run, the goal should be a gradual reduction of VAT to 10%.
Taxing all incomes equally and facilitating corporatization is crucial. There should be no new exemptions in the income tax system, and all sources of income need to be taxed. For equity reasons, the marginal income tax should increase. However, the effective income tax of AOPs and individuals should be lower than the corporate income tax to incentivize corporatization. The commission proposes new income tax slabs while suggesting decreased effective tax rates. For example, on an annual income of Rs. 3.6 million, the effective tax rate should be reduced from 12% to 6.38%. Other recommendations include uniformity of the tax regime on all sources of personal and non-corporate incomes, including agricultural income; decreasing the corporate tax rate to 25%; withdrawal of deemed rental income tax, CVT, super tax, turnover tax, and presumptive/final tax; and restoration of investment credits for plant and machinery.
The withholding regime needs to be replaced with an advanced income tax regime. Excessive withholding taxation should be withdrawn, as it operates like an indirect tax and burdens businesses. Withholding should only apply to salaried individuals, while others should pay advanced tax based on 75% of the previous year’s tax. Long-term reforms include reducing the number of withholding taxes and rolling back the WHT regime, except on payroll, interest, dividends, and payments to non-residents. Simplifying and lowering capital gains tax is necessary. Current collection is Rs 10 billion only. Lowering the rate and improving collection can allow capital building. Tax exemptions should be removed, as they create distortions and uncertainty. Removing all exemptions, including those related to income tax, could increase FBR revenues by 37% and raise the tax-to-GDP ratio by 3.36%.
Tax administration reforms are long overdue. These reforms could increase tax revenues by 2-3% of GDP, as seen in countries like Jamaica, Rwanda, and Senegal. The commission recommends mandatory GST registration starting with commercial importers, wholesalers, and tier-1 retailers. Automation and digitization should reduce interaction between taxpayers and tax authorities. The non-filer category should be abolished. Enhancing the capacity of PRAL is also necessary. A Pakistan Fiscal Policy Institute/Budget Office for budgetary and reform with teeth is needed. PIDE, PRIME, and other think tanks should be involved, ensuring that proposals and analyses reach the cabinet and parliament, playing a central role in policy, including international negotiations. The current whimsical approach must end.
The commission has done extensive economic analysis to estimate revenue implications of these reforms. Reforms in customs tariff revenue, including withdrawal of concessions and exemptions, and reduction in under-invoicing and misdeclaration, could bring Rs 314 billion with 36.5% growth over three years. General Sales Tax reforms could yield Rs 2,566 billion in additional revenues with 33% growth in the tax base over three years. Improved compliance in FED could yield Rs 48 billion in additional revenue over three years, assuming a 5% growth rate. Capital gains tax reforms might result in a 20% revenue reduction in the first year but would gradually return to existing levels within three years. Direct tax reforms are expected to result in Rs 1,545 billion over three years, assuming a 27.7% growth rate in the base. Overall revenue gains from tax rationalizations are projected to be approximately Rs 4 trillion, showing a 26% increase in the base over three years.
The PIDE-PRIME Tax Reforms Commission comprises eminent economists and tax experts, including Dr. Nadeem ul Haque, Vice Chancellor of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE); Dr. Ali Salman, Executive Director of Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME); Mr. Shahid H. Kardar, Former Governor of the State Bank of Pakistan; Syed Shabbar Zaidi, Former Chairman of the Federal Board of Revenue; Dr. Ikram ul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court; Dr. Manzoor Ahmad, Senior Fellow at PIDE; Dr. Nasir Iqbal, Head of Macro Lab, PIDE; Dr. Mahmood Khalid, Senior Research Economist, PIDE; and Dr. Khalil Ahmad, Distinguished Research Fellow, PRIME.
Hey very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds also…I am happy to find a lot of useful information here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .
Купить сервер HP Proliant недорого, Получите консультацию перед покупкой сервера HP Proliant
сервер делл купить http://www.servera-hp-proliant.ru/ .
Советы по повышению эффективности с помощью серверов HP
сервера hp купить https://www.kupit-server-hp.ru/ .
Профессиональные сантехники в Сан-Хосе ждут вас!, Надежные услуги сантехника в вашем районе.
Эффективный ремонт сантехники по доступной цене, Звоните прямо сейчас для записи на удобное время.
Быстрый ремонт сантехники в вашем доме, Гарантированное качество услуг по ремонту сантехники.
Эксперт по установке душевых кабин в вашем районе, Профессиональный подход к любой задаче в сфере сантехники.
Качественный ремонт труб в Сан-Хосе любой сложности, Гарантированное устранение проблем с водопроводом в вашем доме.
Решаем проблемы с канализацией в Сан-Хосе быстро и качественно, Звоните для консультации или записи на удобное время.
Специалисты с многолетним опытом готовы выехать по вызову, Экспресс услуги сантехника в вашем районе.
plumber san jose plumber san jose .
It is in reality a nice and helpful piece of info. I¦m happy that you shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.
I haven?¦t checked in here for a while because I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are good quality so I guess I will add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂
Explore the best online schools in Wisconsin, with in-depth analysis.
Join a prestigious online school in Wisconsin, to kickstart your learning experience.
Learn from the comfort of your own home in Wisconsin, with flexible schedules and personalized support.
Boost your job opportunities with an online diploma in Wisconsin, from recognized online institutions in Wisconsin.
Fulfill your learning objectives with an online course in Wisconsin, customized to match your preferences and availability.
Engage with classmates in online discussions in Wisconsin, and build a strong network for your future.
Access resources and materials online for your courses in Wisconsin, to prosper in your remote studying and flourish in your cyber university.
Online Schools in Wisconsin https://onlineschoolwi6.com .
Explore the top-ranked online schools in Missouri, offering quality programs.
Take the first step towards your degree at an online school in Missouri, that fits your schedule and budget.
Looking for online schools in Missouri?, Browse through our top picks.
Obtain a quality education online in Missouri, with experienced faculty members.
How can online schools in Missouri enhance your learning experience?, Learn about the opportunities available.
Connect with fellow online students in Missouri, to collaborate on projects.
Discover the virtual campus of online schools in Missouri, to broaden your intellectual horizons.
Online Schools in Missouri onlineschoolmo6.com .
Find out the leading online schools in Utah, with just a click.
Become a part of a recognized online school in Utah, for a brighter future.
Achieve your educational goals online in Utah, with flexible schedules and quality education.
Connect with other students in online schools in Utah, to expand your knowledge and skills.
Engage in dynamic virtual classes in Utah, for a more immersive educational experience.
Receive assistance and mentorship in online schools in Utah, to help you excel in your studies.
Choose from a variety of programs in online schools in Utah, that suit your future plans.
Progress in your academic journey with online schools in Utah, for a brighter and more promising tomorrow.
Online Schools in Utah http://www.onlineschoolut6.com/ .
Invest in your future with an online school in Louisiana
Online Schools in Louisiana onlineschoolla8.com .
You have brought up a very good points, thankyou for the post.
Top Online Schools in Colorado, Discover the Best Online Schools in Colorado, Start Your Online Education Journey in Colorado, Find the Right Online Program for You, Quality Online Schools for Colorado Students.
Online Schools in Colorado https://www.onlineschoolco1.com .
Find your happy ever after. Join us today! – https://ugy2mr2.auraflirtsdreams.com/dkf8d6u?m=1
Миналата година пътувах с Мистрал Травел и останах изключително доволна! Организацията беше перфектна – от резервацията до самото пътуване. Избрах екскурзия до чешката столица Прага и всичко беше организирано на високо ниво – хотелът беше комфортен, екскурзоводът много компетентен, а планът за пътуването завладяваща и добре балансирана. Благодарение на тях успях да се потопя на културата и красотата на града без никакви грижи. С радост бих се използвала услугите на Мистрал отново и препоръчвам на всички да заложат на техните услуги!
Benefits of online schools in Washington,
Insight into the operation of online schools in Washington,
Strategies for thriving in online schools in Washington,
Comparing online schools in Washington,
Key features of online schools in Washington,
Financial aspects of online schools in Washington,
Identifying quality online schools in Washington,
Obstacles to overcome in online schools in Washington,
Resources for students in online schools in Washington,
Job prospects for online school graduates in Washington,
Training courses available at online schools in Washington,
Flexible scheduling options at online schools in Washington,
Creating a professional network at online schools in Washington,
In-depth programs at online schools in Washington,
The future of online education in Washington,
Hardware and software needed for online schools in Washington,
Feedback from graduates of online schools in Washington,
How to enroll in online schools in Washington,
Advantages of online education for working professionals in Washington
Online Schools in Washington http://www.onlineschoolwa2.com .
Find your perfect online school in Oklahoma, browse degrees and courses.
Get your degree without leaving Oklahoma, benefit from virtual classrooms.
Embrace the future with distance learning in Oklahoma, experience the convenience of online classes.
Choose from a wide range of online schools in Oklahoma, earn your diploma from a respected online school.
Enhance your skills with an online school in Oklahoma, achieve academic success in a virtual classroom environment.
Reach your academic potential through online learning, discover the advantages of virtual classrooms.
Online Schools in Oklahoma https://www.onlineschoolok8.com/ .
Top Online Schools in Kentucky, Discover Your Future, Discover a New Way of Learning, Find the Right Online School in Kentucky, Reach Your Educational Goals, Affordable Online Schools in Kentucky, Online High Schools in Kentucky, Earn Your Diploma, Prepare for High School, Understanding Online Education in Kentucky, Get to Know the System
Online Schools in Kentucky http://onlineschoolky1.com .
After study a number of of the weblog posts in your website now, and I truly like your means of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site checklist and will be checking back soon. Pls take a look at my website online as well and let me know what you think.
Your account has been active! Secure your earnings by logging in now. – http://extras.byethost4.com/?sid=5166
I’m in the mood for something sweet and spicy… you? – https://rb.gy/es66fc?narp
Discover the Best Online Schools in New Mexico, Take Your Education to the Next Level with Online Schools in New Mexico, Experience Flexible Learning with Online Schools in New Mexico, Empower Your Education with Online Schools in New Mexico, Discover a New Way to Learn with Online Schools in New Mexico, Connect with Virtual Classrooms in New Mexico, Start Your Online Education Journey in New Mexico, Take Control of Your Education with Online Schools in New Mexico, Transform Your Education with Online Schools in New Mexico, Discover the Advantages of Online Schools in New Mexico
Online Schools in New Mexico Online Schools in New Mexico .
Find the best online schools in Illinois, browse through the list of online schools.
Achieve your educational goals with an online program in Illinois.
Engaging professors and supportive academic environment.
Take the first step towards your online degree.
Online schools offering a wide range of programs.
Accredited online schools in Illinois.
Affordable online education options in Illinois.
Online schools with high graduation rates.
Advance your career with an online degree in Illinois.
Connect with like-minded individuals in online programs in Illinois.
Online Schools in Illinois http://www.onlineschoolil20.com/ .
топаз оранжевый https://ambertopaz.ru/
Мы поможем вам получить легальные справки для работы, учебы, поездок и других нужд в кратчайшие сроки. Все документы оформляются быстро и соответствуют требованиям законодательства kupit-med-spravki.ru
fantástico este conteúdo. Gostei bastante. Aproveitem e vejam este conteúdo. informações, novidades e muito mais. Não deixem de acessar para saber mais. Obrigado a todos e até mais. 🙂
Гран Канария: идеалното място за почивка, къде да отпочинете на острова.
Гид за плажовете на Гран Канария: изберете идеалното място за слънчева баня.
Гастрономичен тур на Гран Канария: опитайте местните деликатеси.
Почивка на Гран Канария: екскурзии за истински пътешественици.
Почивка и спа на Гран Канария: насладете се на грижата за себе си.
Гран Канария: активна почивка за деца и възрастни.
Семейна почивка в Гран Канария https://bohemia.bg/ .
Find the top online schools in Minnesota | Get your education online with schools in Minnesota | Easy access to online schools in Minnesota | Select the best online school in Minnesota | Embark on your online learning experience in Minnesota | Utilize the benefits of online education in Minnesota | Enroll in accredited online schools in Minnesota | Adaptable online schools in Minnesota for all students | Personalized learning experiences at online schools in Minnesota | Find the perfect fit with online schools in Minnesota
Online Schools in Minnesota https://www.onlineschoolmn4.com/ .
Текстильная реклама с эффектом
печать на ткани на заказ https://www.studiya-pechati-na-tkani.ru .
Discover the top online schools in Idaho, from the comfort of your home.
Achieve your educational goals with online schools in Idaho, to pursue your dreams.
Learn at your own pace with online schools in Idaho, to work around your commitments.
Connect with instructors and classmates through online schools in Idaho, to enrich your education.
Discover the benefits of online education in Idaho, and excel in your studies.
Online Schools in Idaho http://www.onlineschoolid6.com .
Explore the top online education options in South Carolina, Earn your degree without ever stepping foot on a campus.
Balancing work and school is easy with online programs in South Carolina.
South Carolina’s top online schools at your fingertips.
Advantages of choosing online education in South Carolina.
Achieve your goals with online schools in South Carolina.
Discover the right fit for your educational needs in South Carolina.
Embrace the digital age with online schools in South Carolina.
Online education for those with demanding schedules in South Carolina.
Elevate your career with online education in South Carolina.
Transform your future with online schools in South Carolina.
Online Schools in South Carolina http://www.onlineschoolsc6.com/ .
москитные сетки на окна москва
https://moskitka-proizvodstvo.ru/
Leading Online Schools in Idaho, Discover the Right Online School for You, Compare Online Schools in Idaho, Cost-Effective Online Education Options, Save Money While Pursuing Your Degree, Online Schools with Career Support in Idaho, Gain Professional Skills and Connections, Support for Veterans Seeking Education, Honor Your Service with Quality Education, Online Schools for Adult Learners in Idaho, Excel in Your Career with Online Education
Online Schools in Idaho https://www.onlineschoolid6.com/ .
Explore the best online schools in Tennessee, right here.
Looking for online schools in Tennessee?, Take a look at these recommended choices.
Research the top online schools in Tennessee, based on our expert reviews.
Ready to enroll in online schools in Tennessee?, Find all the information you need on this site.
Our website features the top online schools in Tennessee, easily accessible on our site.
Learn all about the best online schools in Tennessee, right now.
Want to find reputable online schools in Tennessee?, Look no further.
Choose the right online schools in Tennessee for you, using our helpful advice.
Explore the top options in online schools in Tennessee, right away.
Start your journey with online schools in Tennessee, using our resources.
Online Schools in Tennessee http://onlineschooltn1.com/ .
Уникальный способ изменить свой гардероб – печать на ткани, проявите свой стиль и вкус.
Уникальные возможности печати на ткани, позволяющие создать неповторимый образ.
Идеальный выбор для модных и стильных людей, которые хотят выделиться.
Сделайте свою одежду уникальной с помощью печати на ткани, которые вы сами выберете.
Удивительные дизайны для нанесения на одежду, чтобы вдохновить вас на необычные сочетания.
Как выбрать идеальный способ печати на ткани, чтобы получить фантастический результат.
печать надписи на ткани http://pechat-nadpisi-na-tkani.ru/ .
Explore the best online schools in Iowa, at your fingertips.
Enroll in one of the leading online schools in Iowa.
Succeed in your studies with online schools in Iowa.
Find the perfect online school in Iowa for your needs.
Gain valuable knowledge at online schools in Iowa.
Take the first step towards your dream job with online schools in Iowa.
Enjoy the flexibility of online schools in Iowa.
Find out why online schools in Iowa are the future of learning.
Join the growing community of online students in Iowa.
Master your studies with online schools in Iowa.
Online Schools in Iowa http://www.onlineschoolia7.com/ .
Discover the top online schools in Pennsylvania, research the best programs and tuition rates.
Earn your degree from a reputable online institution in Pennsylvania, start your journey today.
Study online from anywhere with Pennsylvania online schools, easy access to education from home.
Select the perfect online program for your future in Pennsylvania, take the first step towards your dream career.
Discover the benefits of online education in Pennsylvania, take the next step towards your educational goals.
Online Schools in Pennsylvania http://onlineschoolpa7.com/ .
Explore the Leading Online Schools in Indiana, Online Schools in Indiana: A New Way to Learn
Online Schools in Indiana onlineschoolin4.com .
Новая версия сканера Scanform L5 | Эксклюзивное предложение на сканер Scanform L5 | Почему сканер Scanform L5 – лучший выбор? | Надежный помощник – сканер Scanform L5 | Современное оборудование – сканер Scanform L5 | Продвинутый сканер для работы – Scanform L5 | Подробный обзор сканера Scanform L5 | Сканер Scanform L5: стильный дизайн и функциональность | Лучшая цена на сканер Scanform L5 | Scanform L5: инновации в сканировании
Scanform L5 http://www.an-form-5.ru/ .
https://vip-parisescort.com/
Топовые платформы для дистанционного обучения, которые изменят вашу жизнь.
Получите качественное образование удаленно, доступные в любое время.
Экспертные преподаватели в онлайн школе, для развития ваших навыков.
Присоединяйтесь к лучшим онлайн курсам прямо сейчас, для своего личного роста.
Обучение через интернет для всех возрастов, без ограничения по специализации.
Преимущества онлайн обучения, которое уже здесь.
Онлайн обучение: ключ к знаниям, для развития ваших навыков.
Улучшите свои знания с онлайн обучением, для достижения высоких результатов.
Инновационные методы обучения в онлайн школе, для вашего комфорта.
Online School Online School .
I like this web blog very much, Its a real nice situation to read and find info . “A fair exterior is a silent recommendation.” by Publilius Syrus.
Чего нельзя делать при синдроме беспокойных ног, частые недоразумения.
Секретные методы борьбы с синдромом беспокойных ног, что действительно помогает?
как лечить сбн https://bespokoynyye-nogi.ru/ .
Топ-5 моделей рюкзаков для школьников
high school http://www.azbigmedia.com/business/education-news/here-are-the-15-college-degrees-most-likely-to-make-you-rich/ .
Изучайте дистанционно: онлайн учеба.
по интернет программам.
Станьте экспертом в своей области с онлайн курсами.
Учите новое без напряжения: интернет школа.
Получайте качественное образование удаленно.
Образование в любом месте с онлайн курсами.
Образование на расстоянии через онлайн платформу.
Развивайтесь где угодно с онлайн курсами.
Занимайтесь удобно и эффективно через интернет.
Онлайн образование: выбор современного человека.
Online School http://www.querianson.com/the-future-of-education-exploring-the-advantages-of-online-school .
Choose the best online schools for teaching children, with a wide range of training programs.
Learning at home: pros and cons of online schools, detailed review.
How to choose the best online school for yourself, understand the main points.
How to make learning interesting for your child at an online school, apply proven techniques.
What you need to know before starting an online school, understand the main points.
Choosing between online and offline learning: which is better?, detailed analysis.
Best Online Language Learning Schools, get the most out of it.
Secrets of maintaining interest in learning online, get useful tips.
How to create the perfect distance learning workspace, get detailed instructions.
Pros and cons of online education: What should I choose?, make the right choice.
Best Online Adult Schools: Choose your Learning Path, improve your skills.
Top tips from online learning experts, understand the main points.
How to choose the best online school for learning programming, improve your skills.
Online learning: a new format of education, improve your knowledge.
The best online courses for teaching children, improve your child’s skills.
Secrets of successful learning for children in online format, keep them interested in learning.
Why choose online education for children, get new knowledge.
k 12 online schools https://onlk12-st5.com .
Удивительные образовательные средства с применением 3D-печати, для улучшения учебного процесса.
Революция в образовании: 3D-печать и учебные инструменты.
Успешная реализация 3D-печати в образовательных целях: ключевые аспекты.
Инновационные подходы в учебном процессе: 3D-печать и образовательные инструменты.
Технология 3D-печати в учебном процессе: как использовать с пользой.
Новые методы стимулирования учебного процесса: 3D-печать и образовательные инструменты.
3D-печать в школе: какие преимущества для учебного процесса.
Новые горизонты обучения: 3D-печать как ключевой элемент образовательной системы.
Технологии обучения завтра: 3D-печать и ее влияние на учебный процесс.
Создаем собственные обучающие материалы с помощью 3D-печати: шаг за шагом инструкция.
3D-печать в школьной программе: новые возможности для педагогов.
3D printing educational tools http://habr.com/ru/companies/top3dshopinc/articles/792132 .
сетка от комаров на окна
https://окна-века74.рф/
колеса цена
https://aw.by/news_13968/
Individual approach to each student in an online elementary school
elementary online classes elementary online classes .